Old vs New Tax Regime:
Which Wins for You in 2026-27?
Four worked examples across ₹8L, ₹15L, ₹24L and ₹50L. A break-even table. A decision flowchart. Everything the salary calculator's summary leaves out.
Every year the same question floods payroll inboxes: which regime should I declare? Colleagues compare numbers. HR sends a form. Most people guess, then wonder later whether they guessed right. The answer is not mysterious — it is arithmetic. But the arithmetic has moving parts that most explainers skip.
The short version: the new regime wins when your total claimed deductions (beyond the standard deduction) are low. The old regime wins when they are high enough to overcome the new regime's lower slab rates. The break-even point — the exact deduction level at which one overtakes the other — is different for every income level. Below we run four complete examples to show where it falls at each bracket, and a mini-calculator so you can test your own numbers.
What actually differs between the two regimes
Both regimes tax the same income — salary, rental income, and any other heads that apply. What changes is the rate structure and what you can deduct before the rates apply.
| Item | New Regime | Old Regime |
|---|---|---|
| Standard deduction | ₹75,000 | ₹50,000 |
| Slab rates | Lower (0–30%, 7 slabs) | Higher (0–30%, 4 slabs) |
| Section 80C (PF, ELSS, insurance) | Not available | Up to ₹1,50,000 |
| HRA exemption | Not available | Least of 3 formulas |
| Home loan interest (self-occupied) | Not available | Up to ₹2,00,000 |
| Home loan interest (let-out) | Uncapped (deduct from rental income) | Uncapped (deduct from rental income) |
| Employer NPS (80CCD(2)) | 14% of basic | 10% of basic |
| Meal vouchers (Rule 15(5)(a)) | ₹200/meal | ₹200/meal |
| Section 87A rebate | Up to ₹60,000 if taxable ≤₹12L | Up to ₹12,500 if taxable ≤₹5L |
Four worked examples — the full arithmetic
Example 1: ₹8,00,000 CTC — the entry-level picture
At ₹8L CTC the new regime's rebate advantage is decisive. Taxable income under the new regime (₹8L gross minus ₹75K standard deduction = ₹7.25L) attracts a slab tax of about ₹32,500. Because taxable income is below ₹12L, Section 87A eliminates the entire tax. In-hand: effectively zero income tax.
The old regime cannot match this. Even claiming ₹1.5L of 80C deductions, taxable income is ₹6.25L, slab tax around ₹37,500, and the 87A rebate (≤₹5L threshold) offers no help at this income level. New regime wins at ₹8L for almost everyone.
Example 2: ₹15,00,000 CTC — the middle-income contest
At ₹15L you need roughly ₹3L+ of old-regime deductions to overcome the new regime. HRA + full 80C alone usually does not make it; you need a home loan loss or substantial 80D on top. The break-even point at ₹15L is around ₹3.2–3.5L of claimed deductions.
Example 3: ₹24,00,000 CTC — where the regime argument gets serious
At ₹24L with a genuine home loan loss, substantial HRA and full 80C, the old regime wins comfortably. Without the home loan loss, the margin collapses and the new regime regains the lead. The decisive lever at this bracket is the self-occupied home loan interest (up to ₹2L), which is old-regime only.
Example 4: ₹50,00,000 CTC — high bracket, surcharge territory
At ₹50L the 10% surcharge applies in the old regime (taxable income above ₹50L), adding roughly ₹50,000+ to the tax bill even after deductions. The new regime's surcharge is the same at this level. However, the old regime can still win if rental income losses are large — because an uncapped let-out interest deduction can bring taxable income below the ₹50L surcharge threshold.
At ₹50L CTC with no other deductions, the new regime typically saves ₹60,000–90,000 over the old regime's base rates, and the break-even deduction level rises to roughly ₹8–10L. That is achievable only with multiple properties, a large self-occupied home loan and significant 80D claims. Most ₹50L earners are new-regime taxpayers.
Break-even deduction table by income
| Annual CTC | New regime tax (no extra deductions) | Old regime must beat this | Approx. deductions needed for old regime to win |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹8 lakh | ₹0 (87A rebate) | Also ₹0 at ≤₹5L taxable | New regime wins — old regime cannot match zero-tax at this level |
| ₹12 lakh | ₹0 (87A rebate at ≤₹12L) | Old regime: ~₹62,000 | Old regime cannot win — new regime's 87A rebate eliminates tax entirely |
| ₹15 lakh | ~₹1.26L | ~₹1.30L before any deductions | ~₹3.2–3.5L of deductions |
| ₹20 lakh | ~₹2.02L | ~₹2.37L before deductions | ~₹4.5–5L of deductions |
| ₹24 lakh | ~₹2.28L | ~₹2.87L before deductions | ~₹5–6L of deductions |
| ₹36 lakh | ~₹5.38L | ~₹6.52L before deductions | ~₹7–8L of deductions |
| ₹50 lakh | ~₹10.14L | ~₹12.38L before deductions | ~₹8–10L of deductions |
Figures are illustrative for a resident individual under 60, basic 50% of CTC, PF on the ₹15K ceiling, no employer NPS. Use the salary calculator for your exact numbers.
Decision flowchart — which regime for you?
What changes between regimes that people miss
Professional tax deductibility. Professional tax (₹2,500 cap) is deductible in the old regime only, under Section 16(iii). At the 30% slab this is worth ₹750 in tax — small but real when regimes are close.
Employer NPS ceiling. The new regime allows a 14% of basic employer NPS contribution under Section 80CCD(2); the old regime caps it at 10%. For a ₹24L CTC with 50% basic, that is ₹48,000 extra routed tax-free into NPS in the new regime. This is often the regime argument clincher for people with no HRA or home loan. See the NPS guide for the full picture.
Let-out property — both regimes benefit. Interest on a let-out property is uncapped in both regimes, deducted against rental income. If your interest exceeds rent (the common case), the loss can be set off against salary up to ₹2L in the old regime only; in the new regime it carries forward. This is often the deciding argument for people who rent out a property they bought before the regime question arose. See the home loan guide.
Children's allowances. Education (₹3,000/child/month) and hostel (₹9,000/child/month) allowances introduced by Rule 280 of the 2026 Rules are old-regime only. With two children in hostel, this is ₹2,88,000 of exempt income — a game-changer for people in the 30% bracket who are also paying school fees.
Official sources
Every rate and threshold above traces to primary legislation.